Comments on: The Acid 3 Test http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/ All about WebKit development Mon, 12 May 2008 10:39:02 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.5.1 By: solipsism http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23959 solipsism Tue, 18 Mar 2008 18:39:04 +0000 http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23959 That is waht you should be getting with Safari 3.1 and its accompanying WebKit engine. It bests everyother stable AND beta engines, except for WebKit, of course. That is damn good. That is waht you should be getting with Safari 3.1 and its accompanying WebKit engine. It bests everyother stable AND beta engines, except for WebKit, of course. That is damn good.

]]> By: alienvenom http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23958 alienvenom Tue, 18 Mar 2008 18:09:25 +0000 http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23958 With the newest version of Safari released today (v3.1) I am only able to get 75/100 on Windows. :( With the newest version of Safari released today (v3.1) I am only able to get 75/100 on Windows. :(

]]> By: Sebastian http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23939 Sebastian Thu, 13 Mar 2008 09:03:03 +0000 http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23939 Deirdre just asked me to add to the information above, I'm on PPC (PowerBook G4), and no matter how often I refresh, I am always stuck at 86. This doesn't depend on how many Applications I'm running at the time. Clearing the cache also doesn't make any difference. Deirdre just asked me to add to the information above,

I’m on PPC (PowerBook G4), and no matter how often I refresh, I am always stuck at 86. This doesn’t depend on how many Applications I’m running at the time.

Clearing the cache also doesn’t make any difference.

]]> By: lhawkins http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23938 lhawkins Thu, 13 Mar 2008 04:10:25 +0000 http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23938 Like Jeffrey wrote, I too get different results when I refresh the page. In fact I get 90/100 with the current nightly on first load, but if I refresh I get 88, then 89, then 90 most of the time, although it does seem somewhat related to network latency. If there is a visible delay in the animation I usually get the 88, very time I get a 90 it seems "smoother". Like Jeffrey wrote, I too get different results when I refresh the page. In fact I get 90/100 with the current nightly on first load, but if I refresh I get 88, then 89, then 90 most of the time, although it does seem somewhat related to network latency. If there is a visible delay in the animation I usually get the 88, very time I get a 90 it seems “smoother”.

]]> By: Sebastian http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23935 Sebastian Tue, 11 Mar 2008 09:14:11 +0000 http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23935 I don't know why my last comment does not appear here, but anyways, I said that I'm using the webkit application, not Safari to run the test. I just used Safari to check its version as dngnta suggested. Does anybody have another idea? Thanks! I don’t know why my last comment does not appear here, but anyways, I said that I’m using the webkit application, not Safari to run the test.

I just used Safari to check its version as dngnta suggested.

Does anybody have another idea?

Thanks!

]]> By: Jeffrey http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23934 Jeffrey Tue, 11 Mar 2008 08:23:51 +0000 http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23934 Running Safari 3.0.4 (523.15) with webkit build 30881 gives me 88/100 with an empty cache. After refreshing the page I get 90/100. Test 77 and 78 seem to be failing with an empty cache. Test 77 failed: expected '4776' but got '5550' - getComputedTextLength failed. Test 78 failed: expected '90' but got '0' - getRotationOfChar(0) failed. Running Safari 3.0.4 (523.15) with webkit build 30881 gives me 88/100 with an empty cache. After refreshing the page I get 90/100. Test 77 and 78 seem to be failing with an empty cache.

Test 77 failed: expected ‘4776′ but got ‘5550′ - getComputedTextLength failed.
Test 78 failed: expected ‘90′ but got ‘0′ - getRotationOfChar(0) failed.

]]> By: deirdre http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23932 deirdre Mon, 10 Mar 2008 19:33:20 +0000 http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23932 Sebastian, running a nightly of WebKit with Safari won't change the Safari version. The version you have is the most current release of Safari. If you want to try a WebKit nightly with Safari, the easy way is to download the nightly from http://nightly.webkit.org/ Sebastian, running a nightly of WebKit with Safari won’t change the Safari version. The version you have is the most current release of Safari.

If you want to try a WebKit nightly with Safari, the easy way is to download the nightly from http://nightly.webkit.org/

]]> By: Sebastian http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23929 Sebastian Sat, 08 Mar 2008 21:48:19 +0000 http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23929 Hm... My Safari reports it is Version 3.0.4 (5523.15). Is that not the most current version? Software Update doesn't offer me an update, where would I get it from? Hm… My Safari reports it is Version 3.0.4 (5523.15). Is that not the most current version? Software Update doesn’t offer me an update, where would I get it from?

]]> By: dngnta http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23928 dngnta Sat, 08 Mar 2008 21:27:53 +0000 http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23928 I also got only 87/100 on the most recent nightly builds on Windows. However, I had overlooked an update to Safari 3.0.4 beta in Apple Software Update - once I let that one install, I started getting 90/100 as expected. So if you're not getting 90/100 on the latest nightlies, check to see if the underlying Safari installation can be updated. I also got only 87/100 on the most recent nightly builds on Windows. However, I had overlooked an update to Safari 3.0.4 beta in Apple Software Update - once I let that one install, I started getting 90/100 as expected.

So if you’re not getting 90/100 on the latest nightlies, check to see if the underlying Safari installation can be updated.

]]> By: Sebastian http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23927 Sebastian Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:47:56 +0000 http://webkit.org/blog/158/the-acid-3-test/#comment-23927 I just downloaded and installed the nightly build... When I run the test, I score only 86/100 + some design glitches. I even created a new user, so I would have default settings, but it's still not working. These tests fail: Test 2: reached expectation 13 when expecting expectation 12 Test 11: when inserting <a> into Document with another child: wrong exception raised; code = 1 Test 13: collapsed is wrong after deletion Test 23: no exception for createElementNS('null', ':div') Test 25: failed to raise exception Test 69: Undefined value Test 70: UTF-8 encoded XML document with invalid character did not have a well-formedness error Test 73: expected: 10, got: 1 - click event handler called the wrong number of times Test 74: getSVGDocument failed for referencing an svg document. Test 75: Value undefined (result of expression anim.beginElement) is not object. Test 76: expected: 0, got: 100 - Incorrect animVal value after svg animation. Test 77: expected: 3, got: 0 - getNumberOfChars returned incorrect string length. Test 78: expected: 90, got: 0 - getRotationOfChar(0) failed. Test 79: expected: 34, got: 33 - SVGSVGTextElement.getNumberOfChars() incorrect Am I missing something? Thanks Sebastian I just downloaded and installed the nightly build… When I run the test, I score only 86/100 + some design glitches. I even created a new user, so I would have default settings, but it’s still not working. These tests fail:

Test 2: reached expectation 13 when expecting expectation 12
Test 11: when inserting <a> into Document with another child: wrong exception raised; code = 1
Test 13: collapsed is wrong after deletion
Test 23: no exception for createElementNS(’null’, ‘:div’)
Test 25: failed to raise exception
Test 69: Undefined value
Test 70: UTF-8 encoded XML document with invalid character did not have a well-formedness error
Test 73: expected: 10, got: 1 - click event handler called the wrong number of times
Test 74: getSVGDocument failed for referencing an svg document.
Test 75: Value undefined (result of expression anim.beginElement) is not object.
Test 76: expected: 0, got: 100 - Incorrect animVal value after svg animation.
Test 77: expected: 3, got: 0 - getNumberOfChars returned incorrect string length.
Test 78: expected: 90, got: 0 - getRotationOfChar(0) failed.
Test 79: expected: 34, got: 33 - SVGSVGTextElement.getNumberOfChars() incorrect

Am I missing something?

Thanks
Sebastian

]]>